February 11, 2025, ~21 km, ~750m climb, little natural surface (~50% dumped gravel, ~30% plastic waffle tread), Mangatepopo to Ketetahi (south to north), Ketetahi Hot Springs & hut no longer accessible.
Local boosters claim this as “the world’s best day hike.” Not even close. Overhyped, massively overcrowded. “Km 12 to 18 an absolute slog.”
There are two big strikes against this hike now: the insane-sized Lord of the Rings-induced crowds coming here to “Mordor“, and trail re-location and addition of many hundreds of needless stairs that was still ongoing in 2025. The trail changes are as unfortunate as any we’ve seen on thousands of trails on six continents (especially considering the huge taxpayer expense.)
The trail crews with their “baby bulldozers”, helicopters, kms of gravel, a thousand trees-worth of wood (lining both sides for kilometres and forming countless needless stairs), and many kms of mud-reducing “waffle” plastic trail tread have now eliminated most of the natural trail. We’re all in favour of mud-reduction; we know mud (having backpacked 90 kilometres of Tasmania’s stunning South Coast Track along the Indian (Southern if you’re Aussie) and Pacific Ocean shorelines.) But….
…the addition of most of the hundreds and hundreds of stairs is both needless and painfully jarring (even, we were told, on young knees!). A count a few years back totalled 199 flights of stairs, & that’s since been greatly increased. Long stretches of quite fine, reasonably inclined trail segments have and are being converted into little serial “ski jumps”, only instead of jumping there’s 3 or 4 wooden stairs.
That’s right; the very gently declining trail bed is actually deliberately raised up above a perfectly fine grade to create an elongated terrace ending at a previously non-existent “ski jump”/ drop-off where a pre-fab set of stairs is inserted. (Worse, these are stairs with a too-close horizontal distance for a normal stride). This is already so hated by many hikers that they are creating and using paralleling “normal” trail treads on one or both sides of the stairs.
Perversely, seeing their needless stairs circumvented by furious hikers (we talked to many), the trail crews are now blocking these bypasses with boulders. On top of awesome Isthmus Peak north of Wanaka (1100m climb in 8 km with zero stairs) we ran into a couple that was still seething about those needless stairs a week after having done the hike. At another recent “stupid stairs” addition on the bottom part of the short Blue Lakes-Tasman Glacier Trail at Mt. Cook National Park, where every flight has been circumvented by hikers, we sadly watched small children doing fine on the normal trail grade, but where it had been wiped out by steps, unable to handle them for long.
Or one has only to visit the enchanting Victoria Park trails in Wellington hiked for many decades by families of all abilities to find trails sloping at twice or thrice that of the Tongariro Crossing, but without the innumerable needless stairs. Dave has maintained (and built) trails for 40 years for different hiking organizations; this insertion of superfluous stairs (raising the trail bed just to “require” stairs) is not normal behaviour.
And that’s only half of it. To reduce climb, about 90% of hikers go south to north and many (on AllTrails at least) find the latter half of the hike with its 1250 meter drop to be, and we quote, “endlessly mind-numbing,” worsened by the loss (to private property) of the only big highlight of that half (the Ketetahi Hut and hot springs that for decades soothed many a tired hikers’ feet). Some extremely poorly-routed switchbacks share the blame.
Perhaps the recent trail designers were paid by the km, as the re-routes traverse 1/3 km one way across the hillside, then 1/3 km back across the same hill, then repeat, needlessly adding distance. Instead of proper switchbacks that actually incline at an acceptable grade, these are often nearly level, at times even climbing the wrong way back up, mostly just creating needless horizontal bulldozed trail scars across the Lord of the Rings‘ “Plains of Gorgoroth” vicinity (all to allegedly “save alpine vegetation“?)
BTW, the ever-increasing hectares of alpine vegetation being buried by some of the tons and tons of gravel dumped on the trail washing into the adjacent brush is, we suppose, also “saving the alpine“? And topping out at 1856m, this hike is marginally “alpine” anyway; 1/3 of it was naturally forested prior to logging/clearing.
Yes, the Red Crater near the top is dramatic, in a small gravel-pit sorta way. And yes, the Emerald Pools are cool, near the hike’s few, minor thermal steam vents that are at a level about 1/10 of what one finds in the nearby Rotorua area (with the world’s fourth biggest geyser, world’s largest boiling lakes and hot springs, an ancient Maori village on top of thermal features, etc. The best sites in that area are 1) Whakarewarewa Thermal Village, 2) Waimangu Volcanic Valley, 3) Waiotapu Thermal Area, 4) The Buried Village (1886 volcano), not to forget 5) the Kiwi Hatchery/ 6) Agrodome.)
Skip the Tongariro Crossing hike and hit those six instead. Then get to where the really good alpine hikes are, the South Island. In ten hours you can be in Nelson Lakes National Park; do the popular Mt. Roberts circuit anti-clockwise. Oh yes… that trail, supposedly by the same park service as at Tongariro, is wonderfully designed… all perfectly graded, with well-designed switchbacks, and for the whole 8.5km hike with ~650m of climb (and 650m of descent), despite the steeper grades, zero stairs!
Dismiss our diatribe above at your own risk (until you too have needlessly suffered though Kilometres 12 to 18). Excluding the km road walk to the main car parking, the last 3 km and the first 12 km are an above average hike, but this hike is nowhere near the “world’s best day hike.